
8. Financial Analysis and Investment Appraisal
A. Scope and Objectives of Financial Analysis
Within the scope of the circus comprehensive profit planning and control
is viewed as a process designed to help management effectively perform
significant phases of the planning and control functions. This model as
designed for the circus involves:
- development and application of broad and long range objectives of
the enterprise
- specification of enterprise goals
- development of a strategic long range profit plan in broad terms
- specification of a tactical short range profit plan detailed by assigned
responsibilities (divisions, departments, projects)
- establishment of a system of periodic performance report detailed
by assigned responsibilities
- development of follow-up procedures
The financial plan consists of a strategic long range profit plan which
involves sales, cost and profit projections, major projects and capital
additions, cash flow and financing, and personnel requirements. A tactical
short range annual profit plan is also included in the financial plan which
consists of the following subgroups:
Operating Plan:
Planned Income Statement
-
Sales plan
-
Plan of displays
-
Administrative expense budget
-
Transportation expense budget
-
Appropriation type budget (show diversification from the usual practice,
promotion, advertising)
Financial Position Plan
Planned Balance Sheet
-
Assets
-
Liabilities
-
Owner’s equity
In the initiation phase of the circus feasibility, attention should rather
be paid to the long range plans in order to appraise the investment costs
including, recruitment and training of the show people, animal acquirement
expenses, trucks and trailers, tent and electrical construction, ring decoration,
costumes as well as variable cost estimates such as transportation expenses,
salaries of the staff, rents for the area. However, it is not possible
to determine at this point every accounting transaction as all the cost
items could not be determined prior to the detailed development of the
company procedures.
B. Analysis of Cost Estimates and Basic Accounting Statements
There are several cost factors affecting the cost accounting of the
company. Parallel to the number of the cost figures, there are some ways
to estimate these costs. A brief summary of the costs are listed below:
-
Salaries and wages : There are 67 employees working for the company, fourty
of whom are hired for the circus shows. Additional to the patents of the
show characters, some money is paid annually. From the data that average
annual salary of a citizen is $15,000/year (Book of marketing by Evans/Berman)
,the average salary of an employee may be estimated to be:
$[15,000*(1+70%)]*(40/67)+$[15000*(1+20%)]*(27/67)=$24,300,
which means that average income of the show characters are
about 70% higher than the average of USA wheras those of technical and
administrative staff is assumed to be 20% higher. Additionally, a well-known
showman is hired for the ads and brand. This is estimated to bring a cost
of $100,000 annually. Briefly the total employee cost will be $24,300*67+$100,000=$1,728,100
annualy.
-
The tents should be constructed on large areas. The rental cost incurred
by the area may be difficult to estimate, but we can find an upper bound
of $1000 for a two-days show. The total renting cost would then be ($1200/show)*(270
shows/year)=$324,000/year.
-
The transportation vehicles are hired as a beginning investment, which
is assumed to cost $82000/truck*12trucks=$984,000/year. The cost of the
transportation is just the mileage cost of the trucks and trailers. The
annual tournee requires a travel of about 10000km.(estimate from scale).
The average mileage cost is about $1/km/vehicle. We have 12 vehicles in
total. Then the total cost becomes 20,000km/yr*12 vehicles*$2/km/vehicle=$480,000/year.
Another means of transportation, railroads will probably cost less but
not considered during this analysis.
-
As found in their web site, an Australian circus (Ashton’s Circus) states
that all of the properties for a circus establishment cost around $2,500,000.
This figure in sum includes tents, costumes, ring decoration, equipments
of the acrobats and magicians, electrical installations, cages and other
relevant material. With the purchase of new equipment and extended quality
this number may become $3,500,000. For a planning horizon of 10 years (with
no inflation assumption, an annual interest rate of 4%), the annual payments
is assumed to be: $3,500,000*(A/P,4%,10)=$3,500,000*0.12329=$431,515
Moreover, annual interest expense of the loan made assuming a 5% fixed
interest rate is, $3,500,000*0.05=$175,000.
-
The depreciation of the investments are smoothed to 10 years. Annual depreciation
cost =$3,500,000/10years=$350,000/yr.
-
For the insurance of the investments 6% premium is paid. The percentage
is the intuitive estimation for the risk of the business considering the
business fluctuations.Hence the insurance cost becomes: $3,500,000*(6%)=$210,000/yr.
-
Advertising and promotional budget can be calculated to be 10% of the expected
annual ticket sales, which is simply:
0.10* 270shows*1300audience*$19.565=$686,731.5, where 270 shows per
year is the previously calculated number of shows, 1300 audience is the
average expected fill rate out of 1500 seat capacity (in conjunction with
Ashton’s Circus experience), and finally $19.565 the average ticket price
is a weighted average of prices of each cycles. The price level established
by the marketing is essentially determined with respect to the competitors
prices and set as $23.5 for the red cycle cities, $19.5 for the yellow
cycle cities and $17.5 for the blue cycle cities. The average price is:
$22.5*(14+1)/46+$19.5*10/46+$17.5*21/46=$19.565 where the headquarter
city is included in the red cycle and 46 is the overall number of cities
served.
-
Overhead and other pertinent costs including administrative expenses, the
basic food and nutrients, supply materials, utilities, maintanance and
construction costs, etc. may be estimated to be around 30% of the total
yearly costs excluding depreciation, which equals
30%*(salaries inclusive of training costs+rents +transportation costs+leasing
costs+insurance costs+advertisement) = 0.30*(1,728,100+270,000+480,000+504,000+210,000+686,731.5)
= $1,163,649
-
Income tax is assumed to be 30% .
-
Sales revenue is calculated as [($22.5*8 shows*14 cities)+($19.5* 5 shows*10
cities)+($17.5*5 shows*21 cities)+($22.5*3 shows*1 city)]* 1300 audiance
=$7,020,000
The following table is instructive to grasp the sales revenue calculations
|
Cycle
|
Number of Cities
|
Number of Shows
|
Ticket Price
|
|
Red
|
14
|
8
|
22.5
|
|
Yellow
|
10
|
5
|
19.5
|
|
Blue
|
21
|
5
|
17.5
|
|
Headquarter
|
1
|
3
|
22.5
|
-
Vendor fees is simply the total number of audiance times $1 (average snack
and drinks sales per person), which is 1300audience/show*270shows*$1=$351,000.
Souvenir sales is simply the total number of audiance times $1 (average
souvenir sales per person), which is $351,000.
-
An annual marketing cost of $579,000 is incurred as discussed in the Marketing
section.
C. Project Financing
Financing of the resources used in order to initiate the business is
done by using a 10 year loan, to be taken from a bank of which the interest
rate is assumed to be around 5% which was already discussed in the previous
section. This number was generated from the recent market statistics of
Federal Bank of USA. If the income statement submitted in Figure 3 is carefully
examined, it can be stated that the payback period turns out to be 3 years
assuming that the profits after tax figure is stable at least during this
period. Although there is no immediate need and reasoning to prepare a
balance sheet at this point, a pro-forma balance sheet representing the
end of the first operating year estimated that the company will incur is
presented in Figure 4. Since the real cost items and the opportunities
of business can only be realized during the lifecycle of the company no
what-if analsis will be made at this point, as most of the calculations
are based on realistic but not actual assumptions. In the preceding section
the effects of uncertainity to the financial decisions will be analyzed
which is a situation much closer to reality.
D. Economic and Financial Evaluation Under Conditions of Uncertainity
The existence of harsh competition in the eastern region of the continent
as well as the Canadian region make the demand estimation difficult in
the sense that 46 markets with three distinct business structures that
are entered are subject to intensive marketing efforts of both national
and domestic circuses. Therefore the construction of a loyal customer base,
being eligible to create new games and shows that will take the company
one step further and endeavours to enter new promising markets while increasing
the capacity, and segmentation of the prices are primary concerns. The
financial assumptions made in the preceding sections are firmly related
with the financial market conditions as well. For instance the interest
rates, lease prices, equipment and supplies prices, fuel prices and the
price of land are all closely releated with the financial decisions and
their consequences.
